OpenAI. (2024). Digital contract illustration without text [AI-generated image]. DALL•E.

The Legal Implications of Online Consumer Contracts

In today’s digital age, we often encounter online consumer contracts when signing up for a new app, making a purchase, or even browsing a website. Usually presented as terms and conditions, these agreements can seem like another obstacle to getting what you want.

Most people quickly scroll through them and click “I agree” without a second thought. However, it is important to realize that these online contracts are legally binding. That is why it is important to understand what you are agreeing to before you sign.

This article breaks down the legal implications of online contracts, explaining common clauses such as arbitration agreements, liability waivers, and data-sharing permissions, and discussing how they might affect you in the event of a dispute.

The Legal Implications of Clicking “I Agree”

When you click “I agree” or “I accept” on an online consumer contract, you enter into a legally binding agreement as if you had signed a physical document. While this process may seem simple, these contracts often contain terms that govern:

• How disputes will be resolved
• What rights you may be giving up
• How your personal information will be used

It is important to familiarize yourself with these terms because you may unknowingly waive your right to sue or allow companies to use your personal data unexpectedly.

Case Law on Online Consumer Contracts

• Specht v. Netscape Communications Corp. – The Second Circuit ruled that users must receive reasonable notice of terms for contracts to be enforceable. Hidden clauses, such as arbitration agreements, are not binding if users did not have clear notice.
• Meyer v. Uber Technologies, Inc. – In contrast, the court ruled Uber’s terms enforceable because they were clearly displayed, and users clicked “I agree” knowingly.

These cases show that reasonable notice and user consent are crucial for enforceability.

Common and Standard Clauses in Online Consumer Contracts

A. Arbitration Agreements in Online Contracts

Arbitration clauses require disputes to be resolved through arbitration rather than court litigation. While arbitration can be quicker and less costly, it often favors the company.

• Arbitration may limit evidence gathering and appeals.
• Users should confirm whether arbitration is binding or non-binding.

Case Example: In Teta v. Go New York Tours Inc., the court emphasized that users must have clear notice and consent for arbitration agreements to be enforceable.

B. Liability Waivers in Online Consumer Contracts

Liability waivers, or disclaimers, often appear in online contracts to protect companies from lawsuits. For example, an online fitness program may require users to waive liability for injuries.

Key issues with liability waivers:

• Often hidden in lengthy terms and conditions
• Written in complex legal language
• May restrict consumers’ ability to seek recourse

Case Example: In Gross v. Sweet, the New York Court of Appeals held that liability waivers must be clear, unambiguous, and not against public policy. Overly broad waivers may be invalid.

C. Data-Sharing Permissions in Online Contracts

Data-sharing permissions allow companies to share or sell user data such as browsing history, purchasing habits, and location information.

• Users may unknowingly permit targeted advertising or third-party sales of personal data.
• Privacy risks increase when data is not clearly disclosed.

Case Example: In People v. Sephora, Sephora faced penalties under the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) for failing to disclose that it sold consumer data to third parties.

Practical Tips for Reviewing Online Consumer Contracts

• Take Your Time – Read terms carefully, especially arbitration, liability, and data-sharing clauses.
• Understand Arbitration Clauses – Confirm the scope, jurisdiction, and whether arbitration is binding.
• Check Data-Sharing Terms – Review privacy policies and opt-out options if available.
• Know When to Walk Away – If terms are overly restrictive, consider alternative services.

Conclusion: Protecting Your Rights in Online Consumer Contracts

Online consumer contracts are a staple of the digital era, but their legal implications can be significant. Clauses such as arbitration agreements, liability waivers, and data-sharing permissions can limit your rights and expose you to risks.

By carefully reviewing these contracts and understanding common provisions, you can make informed decisions, protect your legal rights, and avoid unknowingly giving up important protections.